Central Texas Weather and News Authority
Home  ·   News  ·   Weather  ·   Sports  ·   Politics  ·   Job Board TV  ·   CarSoup  ·   Food  ·   Calendar  ·   TV  ·   Contact Us  ·   10 Cares  ·   Our Town Texas
National News · Health · Golden Apple · Money · Entertainment · Soldier Stories · OffBeat News · Religion · Gas Prices · Lottery · Blogs · Fun & Games · News Tips
KWTX Gift Shoppe - Shop Now!
Poll Question
There are currently no active polls at this time.
Click here to view other polls on our site and past poll results.
Health Features
Buddy Check
Texas Couple Headed To Prison For Deadly Dog Attack Save Email Print

A | A | A

(October 14, 2008)--A Stephens County couple whose pit bulls fatally mauled a 7-year-old neighbor must serve seven years in prison after what was evidently the first conviction under a new Texas law named in honor of a Central Texas woman that holds owners responsible if their unsecured dogs injure or kill someone in an unprovoked attack off their property.

Crystal Michelle Watson, 28, and Jack Wayne Smith, 45, were convicted Thursday of a dog attack resulting in a death.

The second-degree felony carries a maximum penalty of 20 years in prison.

Authorities say Tanner Joshua Monk was attacked May 18 as he walked toward the couple's house to play with some children.

Deputies had to kill two dogs that tried to attack them.

The stiffer penalties are the result of a measured the Texas Legislature passed in 2007 called “Lillian’s Law” in honor of a 76-year-old Central Texas woman who was killed in 2005 by six dogs that got out of a neighbor’s backyard.

Authorities say the pit bull-Rottweiler mixed-breed dogs attacked Stiles as she rode a lawnmower.

Her husband was inside the couple’s home watching a football game and was unaware of the attack until a passerby knocked on the door.

State Rep. Dan Gattis’ bill allows authorities to charge owners of dogs involved in deadly attacks with second-degree felonies, which carry potential penalties of two to 20 years in prison.

More Stories
Justice Department Faults State’s Treatment Of Mentally Disabled

Texas Modeling Studio Owners Plead Guilty

Prison Board Chief Backs Cell Phone Crackdown

Waco Council Approves Homeless Program Grant

Report: Fort Hood Soldier Died Of Drug Overdose While Home On Leave

Fire Heavily Damages Another Central Texas Home

Former Texas Inmate Denied Bond In Murders Of Daughter, Friend

Missing Central Texas Alzheimer’s Patient Found

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Pissed off mommy Location: texas on Nov 6, 2008 at 07:46 AM
after looking at the website below, I am more outraged than ever before...I hate theses dogs..and until you pit lovers go through it yourself, you will never understand. I say kill them all, these dogs are worthless and the owners should be responsible for their pets actions and their stupidty

Posted by: Bill Location: Johnson on Nov 2, 2008 at 08:09 AM
These pit bulls can flip-out at any time, for any reason. See for yourself: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNbSDMTRM5E

Posted by: shelly Location: temple on Oct 20, 2008 at 01:51 AM
I am so glad the neighborhood I built my house in Banned owning / keeping pit bulls in the neighborhood. It was the best thing for me and my family. I am glad they passed the law..I only hope and pray they stay with it.

Posted by: seriously... Location: waco on Oct 16, 2008 at 03:06 PM
It is a proven fact that pit bulls have smaller brains than average dogs... that is why they have more of a tendency to lash out and attack.. they dont know better. And it doesnt matter how you raise them... eventually they will attack. Funny.. smaller brains... just the owners who got the deadly and dangerous dog in the first place.

Posted by: j Location: waco on Oct 16, 2008 at 02:57 PM
I see alot of people talking about how the dog turns on you or the animal turns on you. I see alot of people saying they raised pits from pups and never had a problem. But let me say this. I have never heard of a yard full of labs or cocker spaniels get out of thier yard and chase down a child or attack a woman on a mower. you talk about how protective they are. I watched on the news about a pack of pits that tore through a womans screen door of her house an dmalled her. How is that protective. In the wild they call it pack hunting. I understand there are many dogs of other breeds and even mixed breeds that are vicious. But none carry that trait nearly as much as a pit. A friend of mine had a pit that "would never hurt anyone" until the dog snapped at my 1 year old. Needless to say he buried the dog later. you can all say what you like I think justice was served.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: temple on Oct 16, 2008 at 01:41 PM
Im so glad to see that . My neighbor has a pit that always gets loose and i have 3 year old twins. I told her the next time it comes in my yard im just gonna kill it. If i get in trouble, o well. Its better than waiting till it kills one of my twins then be left saying why didnt i do something to prevent it. I told her if you want to have a pit you must take the responsibilty that comes with it. If it comes in my yard 1 more time, i gonna shoot it, no questions asked.

Posted by: Anonymous on Oct 16, 2008 at 01:12 PM
That's good, they needed to go to jail. Anyone who has dogs that hurts/maims/kills people ought to be put in jail because that's a weapon same as a gun. The only difference is hopefully your gun isn't running loose.

Posted by: doggonit has lost it on Oct 16, 2008 at 01:03 PM
Killer Chihuahua?? LOL Your husband is alive duh! Good thing they were not pits! Most have not heard of the "killer hamster", but I've got scars to prove it. They were acting like a pack and I feared for my life!!

Posted by: Pitbull Hater Location: Waco on Oct 16, 2008 at 11:29 AM
I have had pitbull exposure through many years and every single one eneded up hurting someone. One pitbull killed many animals ansd the grandchild of a dear friend who insisted beforehand the dog woauld not hurt a flea. So don't give me that crap about pitbulls not dangerous. All dogs can attack, bite or maul you, but the pitbull intemds to do that and kill you as well. The pitbull is a dangerous dog bred to be a killer. Kill all pitbulls on sight.

Posted by: Patriot Location: Texas on Oct 16, 2008 at 10:57 AM
This debate on pits has been around several times. I remember when this happened. I can't even fathom the horror this 7 yr old boy was going through, alone, while these 2 dogs were ripping him apart. The sentence of 7 yrs in prison is not even half of what the owners could and should have gotten. But, it's a start. I read an article a while back that stated all pitbulls were being banned on post at Ft. Hood. People are tired of senseless dog attacks, careless owners and taking a stand against this killer breed.

Posted by: Anonymous on Oct 16, 2008 at 10:12 AM
It doesn't matter does it? If you have a DOG that kills someone you are now going to jail. So deal with it. Quit worrying about whining that YOUR pit bull would NEVER............my bet is these owners said the same thing.

Posted by: doggoneit Location: temple on Oct 16, 2008 at 09:23 AM
this is such an emotional topic. dogs can be wonderful, loving creatures. or totally vicious animals. I would say that 99% fall somewhere in between. same as people. you often hear killer's families as saying...he wouldn't hurt a fly. it comes down to circumstances most of the time. I believe that if you own a dog, you are responsible to feed, clothe and train them. you are responsible for his actions, just like you should be for your children. except we really don't put our children "to sleep" for attacking others, or biting... as to killing all of the pit bulls, well, maybe we should just kill all of the dogs. Most have not heard of a "killer chihuaha", but my hubby has scars where he was bitten by three of them, they were acting as a pack. but that just does not make the news like a "big bad pit"

Posted by: Shelly Location: central Tx on Oct 16, 2008 at 08:42 AM
Sherry, I agree with you 100%. I have a german shephard...She is very gently and sweet, but I never once think she could not hurt, bit or attack anyone. Any dog can attack, I have had a damn rat dog attack me on scene and was hanging from my boot, size doesnt matter...you never hear of a poodle, beagal or any other breed killing a person. I feel if you are going to have a dog, that is labled a dangerous dog, then you need to do what is best for teh people and keep them restraigned, weather its a leash or inside. I never allow my dog to go out my house without leash. I was there for Lillians attack, and there is not a day that goes by I dont remember....I am glad for the law. I just hope the pet owners take more responsibility on protecting not only their pets and themselves, but the community they are living in.

Posted by: anonymous Location: waco on Oct 16, 2008 at 12:29 AM
glad for the jail time.. all owners of viscious dogs who attack must be held accountable.i can't imagine why anyone would want that kind of liabilty walking around their yard ,just waiting to get out and attack the first thing they see running.

Posted by: anonymous Location: Austin on Oct 15, 2008 at 10:17 PM
This bill was late in coming. Way too many dog owners should have already been serving time. There is no gentle pitbull unless you are "the Dog Whisperer" and I don't anyone who is. It is going to take sending these owners to jail many times before those who don't get it start making sure their dogs do not get out roaming around. I am ALWAYS for a person's life over a dog. There is just no way there is an excuse for this. Not once. Thank goodness for those who passed this bill. No child should be dying from a dog attack.

Posted by: Pitbull Owner Location: Killeen on Oct 15, 2008 at 09:32 PM
I agree that there should be stiffer laws for people who let their dogs run around loose. I keep my dog in a prviacy-fenced backyard. We do not train him to be mean but as someone said earlier because he is a pit it is his nature to be mean. I never say that my dog want bite because he has teeth, I think anything with teeth will bite. Periodical out the day I will check to see if he is still in the yard because you never know, a dog may find a way out of confinement. Pet owners do need to be educated. I know I would be so angry with myself if my pit were to harm a human or another animal. I do have him for protection however if the person doesn't enter my yard then they don't have to worry about being attack by my dog.

Posted by: sherry Location: gatesville on Oct 15, 2008 at 08:36 PM
If my dog gets loose and kills a goat, I am responsible and must pay the owner for the dead goat. It should be the same for a dog that kills a person - the owner is responsible since the dog cannot pay for his actions. A person cannot be replaced, however so the owner must pay with another form of punishment: prison. Plain and simple. I am tired of people not being responsible for their choices and actions. If you choose to keep a dangerous dog, you should be held responsible for his actions.

Posted by: Me Location: Here on Oct 15, 2008 at 08:26 PM
I'm glad to see that dog owners are finally being held responsible for their dogs actions. To those who say it is not the pit bulls fault when it is aggressive, but is the owners, is BS. Yes owners do train their dogs to be aggressive and to fight, but pit bulls are a hell of a lot more prone to attack and kill on their own than other breeds, regardless of how their owners raised them. Pit bulls are good for nothing else but being aggressive fight dogs, end of story. You want to call me uneducated? I guess the statistics lie, and the countless news stories about "woman/man/child mauled to death by pitbull" are lies as well. Tell me the last time you read a headline that stated "man/woman/child attacked and killed by labrador" or "child killed by neighbors beagle"????? Didn't think so.... its always a pit bull, want to tell me that they wouldn't harm a fly now? Keep your false BS to yourself and keep your pit bulls locked up.

Posted by: Anonymous on Oct 15, 2008 at 08:15 PM
"My kids are around pit bulls every day. In the '70s they blamed Dobermans, in the '80s they blamed German shepherds, in the '90s they blamed the Rottweiler. Now they blame the pit bull." - Cesar Millan Pit bulls get a bad rap because of irresponsible owners. Many people consider the look or popularity of a breed before thinking about whether the dog works for their lifestyle. Please evaluate your lifestyle before taking on the responsibility of a pit bull. Jon Stewart of The Daily Show with Jon Stewart owns two pit bulls: Shamsky & Monkey. President Theodore Roosevelt, President Woodrow Wilson, singer Kevin Federline, radio personality Ira Glass, actor Fred Astaire, General George Patton, actor Michael J. Fox, actor Jan Michael Vincent, actor Jack Dempsy, Thomas Edison, singer Madonna, movie star Brad Pitt, actress Bernadette Peters, comedian Sinbad, actress Linda Blair, actor Humphrey Bogart, musician Usher, comedian Mel Brooks, actress Ann Bancroft, actor Jan Michael Vincent, singer Pink, actress Eliza Dushku and actress Kelli Williams are just a few other celebrities who own or have owned a pit bull.

Posted by: Anonymous on Oct 15, 2008 at 05:24 PM
Joe and Pitbull Hater, you are both ridiculously ignorant. I was RAISED around pitbulls, although they were very protective over the children that were always around, they weren't the slightest bit dangerous. They never did hurt a fly.

Posted by: former pitbull's momma Location: Waco on Oct 15, 2008 at 05:23 PM
I had a pitbull that I raised from the time he was 8 weeks old until he was 3. He had aggressive tendencies towards children and men. Being the only male in the house he felt he had to protect me. I had to get rid of him because AFTER I had him fixed he lashed out at me unprovoked. I watched him for a few more weeks to see if possibly he was hurting from the surgery. He wouldn't come near me after his nueter. Everyone joked that it was because I'd taken his manhood away. It was no joking matter. I couldn't risk him hurting someone or me. It was very hard to do because he was my baby, he slept in the bed with me every night since I'd gotten him. After the surgery something in him changed. Point is some people get a good dog and some people get a bad dog no matter how good they're raised. I will never own another again, because of the stress and anxiety that comes along with the responsibility. I still miss him though. I now have a silly, goofy, but loving chocolate lab (female).

Posted by: Misty Location: Thorndale on Oct 15, 2008 at 04:52 PM
I had a pitbull, my mom has a black lab. Her dog has bit EVERYONE in my family, and a few of my sons friends. My dog would do nothing but get in your lap UNLESS he felt like himself or one of us were in danger. Then he would let out a fierce growl. Anon, I agree with you. My pit was never chained, he was house broken, and slept inside with us. He was not thrown in the backyard and neglected. So to all your hatters, you need to find out how the animal was treated before you blame them. They are like children - they learn from what they are being taught!

Posted by: stacy Location: killeen on Oct 15, 2008 at 04:26 PM
i resent the fact that someone said pitbulls should be killed on sight. I have had 2 and they were wonderful dogs, and were protective of us, but never attempted to harm anyone. Its not just dogs that turn on people, other animals do as well. This is the world we live in, and I feel for the people whose child or loved one was killed by an animal, I myself was attacked by a chow dog on my backside and required 200 stitches and 2 drain tubes, so I know how animals can turn, but its not just pitbulls. ANY ANIMAL CAN TURN ON YOU!!! Plus its all in how you raise the pet and treat the pet as well, so just because you hear the word pitbull, does not mean that its a vicious dog!

Posted by: Me Location: Temple on Oct 15, 2008 at 03:00 PM
The owners should NOT be going to prison. This was a animal who commited the crime and i belive the animal was put down correct? So in this case we will kill the dog plus ruin the lives of 2 other people. Its a terrible tradgedy and i feel for the family of the lost but come on this is not right. Prison for a husband and wife, c'mon get real and set these people free. Dof already paid for the act and now someone else has to pay

Posted by: Victim of Dog Attack Location: Killeen on Oct 15, 2008 at 02:58 PM
It's a good thing that didn't happen in Killeen! Last week as I sat in my own front yard with my small dog, a pit bull attacked. It was trying to kill my dog and was going through me to get to him. I was bit once on the arm, but not bad. I called KPD as the attack was happening. They told me to call animal control and hung up on me! Good thing my brother was there, or I would have been severly injured and my little dog would have been dead. I was running out of energy very fast and could not have fought that pit bull off much longer. If you're in Killeen and you get attacked by a dog, don't call KPD, they won't come help you. Get a gun and shoot the dog yourself!

Posted by: Ann Location: Temple on Oct 15, 2008 at 01:44 PM
I am not a pet lover, but I regard pet owners' feelings toward their dogs. But if your dog attacks/kill someone then you should be held accountable. I am glad there is prison time and not just a fine.

Posted by: PM Location: Gville on Oct 15, 2008 at 01:14 PM
Look, Janet, it is not about placing blame. Look at the statistics. And I don't care if it is pit bulls or a pack of teacup chihuahuas, if they kill someone, then the owner should be held completely responsible.

Posted by: Jessica Location: Temple on Oct 15, 2008 at 10:08 AM
This is to Joe and Pitbull hater: Have either of you ever owned a pitbull? I totally agree that the owners need to be held accountable for the actions of their dogs. HOWEVER ANY DOG WILL BITE, it has everything to do with how they are treated and raised. When I was a child my family had a pitbull that was a former fighting dog,and he was the BEST DOG that I have ever had. Pitbulls have a bad rap that is uncalled for. Yes they can be dangerous dogs, ever heard of German Shepards, Chows, Rotteweilers, Great Danes, Aktas etc. Please do not base your opinion of these animals on what you have heard. Because they can be one of the best dogs a person could ever have.

Posted by: Janet on Oct 15, 2008 at 09:47 AM
People do not want to be educated. They want to blame. Just like this is a nation of suing for greed, it's a nation of blame. Any dog, has the potential to turn on humans. ANY DOG! And the one poster who said "and if you think a pit bull would not hurt a fly just wait awhile he will sooner or later." obviously is one who will not educate himself.

Posted by: Joe Location: Waco on Oct 14, 2008 at 10:39 PM
To Anon: The problem with pit bull owners is they all good owners and do not train there dogs to be killers, and if you think a pit bull would not hurt a fly just wait awhile he will sooner or later.

Posted by: Pitbull Hater Location: Waco on Oct 14, 2008 at 08:25 PM
Fantastic! There need to be consequences for owners of dogs that fatally attack someone. The old excuse..he was so sweet and loving is bulls**T and would never hurt a flea aint gonna cut it anymore....this is great! If it saves one life by making people think twice about keeping the potentially dangerous vicious types of dog breeds--number One the pitbull....then this law is worth it! Thank you Miss Lillian and your loving family. Your terrible death by pitbull-Rotteweiler- cross vicious dogs was not in vain!!! All pitbulls should be killed on sight!

Posted by: Anonymous on Oct 14, 2008 at 08:10 PM
so when is Texas going to outlaw pit bulls

Posted by: ginny Location: cove on Oct 14, 2008 at 08:03 PM
people should be held responisible for their pets.

Posted by: ann Location: waco on Oct 14, 2008 at 07:02 PM
it should be a LIFE SENTENCE, NOT 7 years. this was murder !! their dogs took a child's life. this is not fair !!

Posted by: shelly Location: Central Texas on Oct 14, 2008 at 06:57 PM
All I can say is " Its about time " I am so glad the owners are finially being held responsible for their pets actions. Its sad to think about all the children and adults killed by dogs when things could of be prevented. Glad to see the law is helping the victims and their familys.

Posted by: Anon Location: Waco on Oct 14, 2008 at 05:07 PM
I believe that dogs act the way their owners raise them. They are taught to be mean and to fight then yes they are going to attack any thing they see. I know alot of people with pitbulls that are as nice as can be and wouldn't hurt a fly. They were also raised by good owners and have never been fought or taught to be mean. Those of you who think that all pitbulls are bad dogs need to be educated. It is all in the way the dog is raised.

Latest News Video
News Video
Job of the Week
Click now to see hundreds of other jobs on Job Board TV!

Part-Time Registered Nurse Labor and Delivery Dept. (7P - 7A) - Qualified candidates must possess a Texas license with two (2) years of experience preferred. Minimum requirement of Associate Degree Nursing (ADN).



Also, take a look at the most recent jobs posted to Job Board TV at KWTX.com:
View More Jobs.
AP Video
KWTX.com Features
Double Dollar Deals
Half Price Deals at Central Texas restaurants and businesses. A new deal every Thursday at 7:00am.
KWTX Half Price Gift Shoppe
Holiday shopping on a budget! Check out the Holiday Half-Off Gift Shoppe at KWTX.com, where you will find $50 gift certificates for only $25, beginning November 10th.
Golden Apple
Your chance to nominate an outstanding teacher. Find out how they are making a difference in classrooms.
Emily Wants to Know
Emily Matthews' inquisitive look at life in Central Texas.
10 On Your Side
Answers from our experts on topics that affect YOU.
Soldier Stories
Stories about what the men and women deployed overseas are doing to make a difference.
Chef Walter
Need a fresh idea for dinner? Check out thousands of FREE recipes