Battle Of The Beard Ends; New Judge Says Hasan Doesn’t Have To Shave

By: Rachel Cox Email
By: Rachel Cox Email
The battle of the beard that overshadowed proceedings and led to the removal of the judge in the case of accused Fort Hood gunman Nidal Hasan is apparently over.

(Sketch by Brigette Woosley)


Hasan’s attorneys asked Col. Tara Osborn almost two-dozen questions Tuesday about her background and possible ties to the case or opinions she may have formed about the case.  She answered no to almost all of them. The defense wants to re-litigate these pretrial issues:

  • Request for a media consultant

  • Request for a victim outreach specialist

  • Request for a change of venue

  • Request to limit testimony from prosecution terrorism expert Evan Kohlmann

  • Request for pretrial hearing for admissibility and standard of proof for aggravation evidence

  • Equal protection motion

 The defense wants Osborn to reconsider these pretrial motions: 

  • AR15-6 rediscovery

  • Related issues on e-mails to White House

  • Constitutional voir dire.

  • Prosecutorial misconduct of after one of the members of the prosecution team got certain training materials

  • Panel members’ ability to take notes

  • Requesting military judges ability to question the witnesses motion to compel that required in camera review

  • Defective referral

  • Motion for daily transcripts

  • Motion for legislative failure

  • Motion dealing with grand jury indictment   

The defense also wants to submit another supplemental questionnaire to the possible jury panel members because there have been several major events across the nation that could affect the trial.  They submitted one in March.Osborn asked both the defense and the prosecution to submit a proposed schedule by Dec. 28 to litigate the issues in January. (Rachel Cox)



FORT HOOD (December 18, 2012)--U.S. Army Col. Tara Osborn, who was named earlier this month to preside over the case of accused Fort Hood gunman Maj. Nidal Hasan, won’t require Hasan to shave.

The issue was the final one that Osborn addressed during a pretrial hearing Tuesday.

“I see you are wearing a beard,” she told Hasan.

“You understand that you are outside of the Army uniform regulations?” she asked.

“I’m not going to hold that against you, but some members of the (jury) panel may,” she said.

Hasan indicated that he understood.

Hasan is awaiting court-martial in the November 2009 shooting rampage at Fort Hood’s Soldier Readiness Center that left 13 dead and two-dozen injured.

On Dec. 4 Osborn was named to replace Col Gregory Gross, whom the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces ousted on Dec. 3.

The court also tossed Gross’ order that Hasan must shave or would be shaved forcibly before the court-martial begins.

The court ruled that the command, not the judge, is responsible for enforcing grooming standards and said Gross didn't appear to be impartial in his handling of the case.

“Thus, taken together, the, decision to remove Appellant from the courtroom, the contempt citations, and the decision to order Appellant’s forcible shaving in the absence of any command action to do the same, could lead an objective observer to conclude that the military judge was not impartial towards Appellant,” the ruling said.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces is the highest-level appellate court for the U.S. military.

Hasan’s court-martial was on hold for months because of the battle over the Army psychiatrist’s beard.

The Dec. 3 decision came in Hasan’s appeal of a ruling in October by the U.S. Army Court of Appeals that Hasan has no right to wear a beard in uniform during his court-martial.

(Read The U.S. Court Of Appeals For The Armed Forces Ruling)

(Read The U.S. Army Court of Appeals Ruling)

The Army Court of Appeals upheld Gross’ finding that Hasan failed to prove the beard is an expression of a sincerely held religious belief and said even if the beard were such an expression, “compelling government interests” also justified Gross’ order that Hasan meet Army grooming standards.

The court also upheld previous contempt findings against Hasan in which he was fined $1,000 six times for appearing in court out of uniform because of his beard.

The defense filed appeals seeking a ruling on whether the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act allowed Hasan to keep the beard.

The first sought to overturn contempt findings against Hasan in previous hearings and to bar any future contempt proceedings over the beard.

The second sought a ruling on whether the act allows Hasan to have a beard while in military uniform during his court-martial.

KWTX-TV News 10 6700 American Plaza Waco, Texas 76712 (254) 776-1330 Fax (254) 751-1088
Copyright © 2002-2016 - Designed by Gray Digital Media - Powered by Clickability 183965501 -
Gray Television, Inc.